ALEC Ranks Hawaii as Worst State in Three Economic Categories


Hawaii’s economic outlook was ranked as the worst state in three categories published in the most recent edition of “Rich States, Poor States” by the American Legislative Exchange Council, (ALEC). They include:

  • Sales tax burden $42.62 per $1,000 of personal income is taken in “sales tax” — (Hawaii does not have a traditional state sales tax but does have the broadest “general excise tax” (GET) in the nation, which when equated to sales tax is the single most burdensome tax on goods in the U.S.
  • Estate/Inheritance tax is levied – 16% estate tax resulting in Hawaii receiving approximately $6.9 million in death and gift tax in 2013.
  • Right-to-work – The option to join or support a union does not exist in Hawaii. Hawaii law requires union membership in order to be employed in most public sector jobs.

Hawaii is also ranked #48 for a top marginal personal income tax rate (11%), and is only beat out as the worst state by New York at 12.7% (#49) and California at 13.3% (#50). At least 9 states do not tax personal income, and most others are in the single digits.

U.S. state corporate tax rates show Hawaii at only 2.4% below (39.2%) the worst state of Iowa which is at 41.6% of combined federal corporate tax and state corporate tax.  Note that Mexico’s combined federal and state tax rate is 30%, Korea is at 24.2%, and Ireland’s combined rate is 12.5%.

As for investment, in 2014 Hawaii ranks the 16th worst state or country out of a list of 77 for a top marginal capital gain tax rate of 29.4%

When it comes to the number for tax expenditure limits, Hawaii ranks one point above the states with the worst or least amount of expenditure limits. 

In the overall ranking for economic outlook, Hawaii came in at #40 out of 50 states, which is an increase of 6 points. That increase can be explained by the #1 rating calculated on our pre-2014 minimum wage increase (ranking based on $7.25 per hour).  It is expected that Hawaii will fall from this top spot as the authors of Rich States, Poor States state that “The Congressional Budget Office recently reported that raising the federal minimum wage from $7.50 to $10.10 an hour would destroy about 500,000 jobs by pricing low skilled workers out of the labor market.  …every 10% increase in minimum wages causes about a one to three percent decline in low wage jobs.  This is no way to help the poor.  …Most small businesses’ primary expense is labor and increasing the minimum wage means increasing labor costs.  This means that some businesses that are on the edge of profitability and cannot absorb these costs will end up going out of business.”

Rich States, Poor States also indicates there is cumulative domestic migration loss of 26,409 people from 2003 to 2012, with a net domestic migration loss of 2.4%.

State Senate Minority Leader Sam Slom stated, “I agree with the authors of Rich States, Poor States when they write “Most politicians know instinctively that taxes reduce the activity being taxed – even if they do not care to admit it. Congress and state lawmakers routinely tax things they consider “bad” to discourage the activity.” We see this when we tax tobacco and alcohol.  Why then, does our Legislature continue to have the highest sales tax burden and some of the highest personal income tax rates in the nation.  When is our government going to get it?  You can’t overtax the people to support bad spending habits, and then expect people to stay and invest in our state.”

Slom added “The Senate Minority has consistently introduced bills to alleviate these burdens.  Unfortunately, the majority has consistently blocked these efforts to relieve taxpayers.”

From the Hawaii State Senate Minority Research Office (edited)

Download the PDF Version of Rich States, Poor States at ALEC

Senate Minority Research Office Press Release (PDF)

State Set To Go Bust Unless Major Changes Are Made In 2015.

From the Hawaii State Senate Minority Office: 808 586-6780


Senator Sam Slom has serious concerns about the state of Hawaii’s finances. Slom said today “The recent Council on Revenues downgrading forecast indicates Hawaii is in a much worse position than what was anticipated. Hawaii is set to go bust in 2016 unless the new Governor and the Legislature make some serious cuts.”

“Senate Minority Research (attached) shows that, based on revenue forecasts, if the State continues to spend at the current rate Hawaii will use up its general fund carryover balances as early as 2016. The small 10% of department funds withheld this year by the Governor’s office will not be enough to stop the freefall as it is just a drop in the bucket ($14m) in a 6+ billion dollar state budget.” says Slom.

Senator Slom adds “Because the State is not constitutionally permitted to borrow from outside sources for operating expenditures, it is likely the State will tap into the Emergency Budget Reserve Fund and Hurricane Relief Fund.[1] Those funds are not large so that will be a small band aid for the problem and will not address the problem of overspending for long. The State and the Legislature will have their work cut out for them to deal with this mess resulting from kicking the can down the road for so many years. The final option to deal with the problem by raising taxes is the least desirable and burdensome for the people because we are already one of the highest taxing states in the nation.”

Attached to this release is the Senate Minority Research Office Article “The Implications of the Council on Revenues General Fund Forecast: What happened to the $844 m surplus?” by Paul Harleman, Budget Director, Senate Minority Research Office, September 15, 2014.

Note: for any clarification or questions pertaining to the financial analysis call Paul Harleman, Budget Director, Senate Minority Research Office 586-6988. Email:


Press Release 9-17-2014 (PDF)

Report:  The Implications Of The Council On Revenues General Fund Forecast: What Happened To The $844 Million Surplus? (PDF 975k)

Article: Hawaii Will Go Bust By 2016, Senate Minority Leader October 1, 2014.

Rail Project re-bid is Intended to Create an Illusion of Lower Costs


From the Hawaii State Senate Minority Office: 808 586-6780

Senator Sam Slom does not believe that dividing the building of nine transit stations into three smaller bid projects is intended to lower costs.[1] Slom said today “The fact that HART is breaking this contract up into three projects of three transit stations each is just a way of creating the illusion of lesser costs. It is not likely to lower costs. Everyone knows if you buy in bulk your unit cost is lower, and the less items you buy the more the unit cost grows. If the project is $110 million more buying bulk, how much more do you think it is going to be buying 3 at a time?”

“The way HART is releasing the information makes it sound like they are doing the public a favor. What this reveals is the rail plan was too optimistic, or the bids and tenders were poorly managed. For a project of this scale the public deserves transparency and honesty. The Senate Minority will continue to strip away the spin and act as the voice for our taxpayers.” says Slom.

Senator Slom adds “It is not too late to cancel the project and cut our losses. That is, in fact, what I would urge the county to do. This is just the start of blowout costs and delays. The cost doesn’t just encompass money, but also a loss of 1500 parking spaces at Aloha Stadium, the destruction of dozens of small businesses, and extended periods of traffic congestion and major road works. The longer the disarray, the more effect on tourism, trade and the community. And who really wants to see a rail along our beautiful waterline?”


Additional Commentary from Senator Slom on KHVH Radio 830 AM.



Voting Issues Scrutinized at Election Commission Meeting

Published to the Hawaii Kai NHB #1 Report  for August 26, 2014.

Testifying at Elections Commission Meeting

The Hawaii State Elections Commission held its post-primary meeting last Friday, August 22 before a packed crowd at the State Office Tower. Chief Elections Officer (CEO) Scott Nago was on the hot seat as a the commission reviewed procedures and troubling issues surrounding this year’s primary election. The public also presented oral and written testimony.

I asked the commission to replace the CEO (as I had in 2012) and fix election procedures to make sure that the integrity of the process can improve by the November 4 general election.

Among the issues that came up in the primary election:

Change of make-up election from a mail-in process to a walk in process at the last minute on the Island of Hawaii after 2 precincts in the Puna district were closed on election day.

Late count of 800 “Discovered” Maui ballots from Hana.

Notification of the make-up election process on the Big Island.

No accountability for past and present errors in the election process by the Chief Elections Officer.

Wrong ballots delivered to precincts in 2012.

No plan B in case of natural or manmade disasters.

Vote counts prematurely released before voting was done.

After the commission met in executive session, it was noted that the Elections Office would be reviewing their procedures.

Senator Slom’s Testimony (PDF Link – August 22, 2014)

Chief Elections Officer’s Report – (PDF – August 21, 2014)

Photo: Senator Slom testified at the Election Commission meeting.

2014 April GET Collections Still Down Compared to 2013

Senator Sam Slom continues to urge spending restraints because of the slow recovery of the state and national economies.

The 2014 April General Excise Tax (GET) collections are still down compared to the same month last year, although slightly improved on March 2014.

GET-8-2014The USA national Gross Domestic Product (GDP) numbers for Quarter 2 are up 4% in comparison to Quarter 1[2], although on an annual basis the GDP numbers for 2014 are relatively low at around 1.1%.

Senator Slom explains “For the short term, it indicates that both the state and national economies are somewhat improving, however, the improvement is only on a quarter-to-quarter basis. This does support that there is only a very slow recovery going on for Hawaii and the nation. Hawaii needs to be frugal in its spending of taxpayers’ monies, as the economy is very fragile at this moment, and both the state and the nation are cash poor.”

“To ride this slow ride out of recession, Hawaii needs to put away some cash reserves, just like our everyday families do. At this time, as the Hawaii Senate Minority has previously indicated, Hawaii is due run out of cash reserves somewhere between 2017-19 if no significant changes are made in cutting costs (or raising revenue), possibly resulting in a constitutional crisis of the unbalancing of Hawaii’s budget.”